Hopkinton, MA
Hopkinton, US
11:00 pm, Tuesday, December 5, 2023
overcast clouds 29°F


Letter to the Editor: UCTC needs better oversight

by | Feb 6, 2023 | Letter to Editor

On Feb. 2, the Hopkinton Independent reported on the Upper Charles Trail Committee (UCTC) meeting regarding discussion of two citizens’ petitions for Town Meeting articles. One article would reorganize the committee under the umbrella of the town’s Trails Coordination and Management Committee (TCMC), and the other would prohibit future spending on a trail along and crossing Hayden Rowe between Nos. 147 and 192.  Regarding the petitions, the UCTC chair rhetorically asked, “What is the rush?” As one who signed the petitions, I ask, WHAT WAS THE RUSH to spend $140,000 of local and state taxpayers’ money for preliminary design of a trail around Marathon School and adjacent town land that will only lead to a route along and crossing Hayden Rowe. The School Committee had voted not to support the route around the school, and the Hayden Rowe route has met with overwhelming public resistance due to safety concerns and impact on private yards and driveways. The proposed articles now seem the only recourse to stop this runaway train.

In December 2021, the UCTC held a public meeting about its proposed routes — including that along Hayden Rowe, which crosses the road three times, goes along the roadside for 2,400 feet, crosses approximately 15 driveways, and crosses either Chestnut Street or Teresa Road. Comments at the meeting were overwhelmingly against the Hayden Rowe route. Despite public opinion and the School Committee’s negative vote (Jan. 13, 2022), in February the UCTC applied for a state grant with town matching funds for preliminary design of the route around the Marathon School that would only make sense if the trail continues down Hayden Rowe.

In April 2022, the UCTC held a public “workshop” where participants could indicate whether they “like” or “dislike” various alternative routes. The route along Hayden Rowe received 23 dislikes and zero likes. The Marathon School route received 11 dislikes and six likes. An alternative route through wooded areas west of the Charlesview neighborhood received two dislikes and 17 likes. Despite having this information on public preferences, the UCTC proceeded to accept and expend the grant.

The UCTC has a difficult job, but it needs to focus on routes where more feasibility study is needed and there is likely public support, rather than wasting more money on a route the public does not want. The TCMC has the broader perspective to oversee the UCTC’s work.

— Chuck Dauchy, Hopkinton

Editor’s note: The opinions and comments expressed in letters to the editor are those of the writers and not necessarily those of the Independent. Submissions should be no more than 400 words and must include the writer’s name and contact information for verification. Letters should be relevant and not primarily for the purpose of promoting an organization or event or thanking sponsors or volunteers. Letters may be edited by the Independent staff for space, errors or clarification, and the Independent offers no guarantee that every letter will be published. For a schedule of deadlines for letters and other submissions for the print edition, click here.


  1. Amy Groves

    I agree.

    Only 10.5% of residents surveyed approved of Segment 7 of the UCTC’s trails proposal. Segment 7 puts a trail along Hayden Rowe right in the busy school district and necessitates introducing three new pedestrian crossings.

    The charge issued to the UCTC by the Select Board was to investigate and propose two or three paths to join the Milford and Ashland trails. The UCTC has been meeting for eleven years and has yet to conduct a proper engineering study on the western alternative to Hayden Rowe. Why?

    Coming from the south, once the trail goes west of Hayden Rowe, it should stay west of Hayden Rowe.

  2. Beth Malloy

    11 years was more than time enough time to get this figured out. The UCTC can not just shove their agenda through, when the citizens are saying no. Time for an over haul of the committee.