In the battle between hotels and vacation rentals, consistency is the winning move. Here’s how to deliver an experience that lives up to your listing and keeps guests coming back.

Hotels have a secret weapon: consistency. No matter where you check in, the bed feels familiar, the towels are fluffy and you never have to hunt for the extra roll of toilet paper. Vacation rentals, on the other hand, can be magical, but sometimes they gamble with guest expectations. One home is stunning, stocked and spotless. The next might leave guests longing for the predictability of a hotel. In today’s competitive market, closing that consistency gap is the key to keeping guests coming back.

The short-term rental boom during COVID created an influx of new hosts. At the time, travelers were not picky. They were simply happy to get away. Now in 2025, guests have choices. Lots of them. Demand has leveled, budgets are tighter and guests are more discerning. A beautiful set of photos might win the booking, but if the in-person experience falls short, your five-star dreams can quickly fade.

The good news is that it is not rocket science to deliver a hotel-level experience while keeping the personality and charm that make vacation homes so appealing. Here are four quick wins that can transform a home from “just another rental” into a guest favorite:

1. Upgrade the basics
Stop thinking of your vacation home as a place for hand-me-down furniture. Guests expect the same quality they have at home or better. Invest in sturdy bed frames, plush mattresses, matching nightstands and well-made couches. Skip the random thrift store décor. Instead, design with purpose, blending comfort with style so every room feels intentional.

2. Master the art of the photo
Your photos are your storefront. Work with a photographer who understands short-term rentals, not just real estate. Stage every room with the lights on, beds perfectly made and key amenities front and center. Show the coffee setup, the outdoor firepit or the game room exactly as guests will enjoy them. Great staging equals more bookings.

3. Audit the guest experience
Before you launch or relaunch, invite friends or family to stay and critique everything. Can they find the silverware without opening eight drawers? Is there a full set of pots and pans? Are the TV instructions easy to follow? Treat their feedback like gold. Eliminate the friction points and make every interaction with the home effortless.

4. Create a ‘no guesswork’ stay
Hotels thrive because guests never have to guess. Replicate that. Stock extra paper products in plain sight. Label switches, remotes and shelves. Provide a simple house manual and a QR code for appliance instructions. The more intuitive your home is, the more relaxed and happy your guests will be.

Consistency is not about making your home look like every other property on the market. It is about keeping your promises. When your photos reflect reality, when every detail works seamlessly, and when guests feel cared for from booking to checkout, you do not just compete with hotels, you beat them at their own game.

Dave Menapace, President
The 5 Star Co-Host, LLC
5strcohost.com

The advertiser is solely responsible for the content of this column, which is a paid advertisement.