hopkinton-independent-logo2x
Hopkinton, MA
loader-image
Hopkinton, US
3:34 am, Wednesday, September 23, 2026
46°F
91 %
Wind Gust: 7 mph
Clouds: 99%
Sunrise: 6:34 am
Sunset: 6:42 pm

SIGN UP TODAY!
BREAKING NEWS & DAILY NEWSLETTER





Letter to the Editor: Herbicides in lake wrong ‘solution’

by | Feb 10, 2026 | Letter to Editor

The most recent article in the Independent concerning our lake sent me to the dictionary to look up the word “collaborate” — a word used by the chairperson of the Sustainable Green Committee [SGC], of which I am a member. One definition was about working jointly on an intellectual endeavor. I can get behind that. Most definitions were about assisting the enemy. This is a problem. Many people confuse collaboration with compromise.

CIG [Citizens Input Group] for Lake Maspenock members have stated that their first preference is to use nontoxic methods of weed management. However, their behavior speaks to a strongly pro-herbicide stance. The SGC would be more than happy to work with the CIG and LMPA [Lake Maspenock Preservation Association] on increasing nontoxic options and seeking funding for these.

Poisoning our ecosystem, our children and all of us who swim in the lake is not a viable option. There is no compromise on this in the position of the Environmental Committee of the SGC. There is no compromise in the written charge of the SGC.

If you are interested in scientific background, I suggest an article in the Guardian on diquat.

I write this to clarify for both journalists and citizens that this is not a “both sides” situation. When something is harmful and wrong, it needs to be dismissed as a “solution.” Can we now work together to make our lake healthier?

— Carol Esler, Hopkinton

Editor’s note: The opinions and comments expressed in letters to the editor are those of the writers and not necessarily those of the Independent. Submissions should be no more than 400 words and must include the writer’s name and contact information for verification. Letters should be relevant and not primarily for the purpose of promoting an organization or event or thanking sponsors or volunteers. Letters may be edited by the Independent staff for space, errors or clarification, and the Independent offers no guarantee that every letter will be published. For a schedule of deadlines for letters and other submissions for the print edition, click here.

1 Comment

  1. gary-bishara lucas

    Thanks for the letter to the editor.

Related Articles

Letter to the Editor: Dangerous intersection ahead

The ramp exiting Interstate 495 northbound onto West Main Street toward town is perhaps the most dangerous I’ve encountered in years. As one exits the interchange onto West Main, there is a total lack of merging roadway, placing vehicles in a dangerous game of...

Letter to the Editor: Kudos to HFD for professionalism

Shout-out to the Hopkinton Fire Department! Smoke detector inspections are typically one of the last hurdles required before closing the sale of a house. My clients replaced the smoke detectors in their home in advance of the inspection with the wrong type of smoke...

Letter to the Editor: Concerns raised about solar agreement

As neighbors who share forests, wildlife habitat and trail connections, we’re asking Hopkinton residents to help ensure that commitments made during the approval of the Frankland Road solar project are honored. In 2020, Seaboard Solar, the original owner of the...

Letter to the Editor: Herbicides wrong approach for Maspenock

I am writing to show my support for stopping the use of PFAS herbicides in Lake Maspenock. I read the letter to the editor in the June 17 edition about this topic, and with our town struggling with PFAS in our water for many years now, I was surprised when I read...

Letter to the Editor: Town could use community garden

Did you know that the Center School property in Hopkinton spans over 11 acres? And that it is getting harder to find new jobs in our wonderful town? A community garden is the solution to both of these problems. Center School has an enormous plot of land, and some...

Letter to the Editor: Maspenock herbicides ‘poisoning’ lake

On June 16, our town will be poisoning Lake Maspenock with Procella, diquat and other herbicides containing PFAS. It is a sad day for the lake I have lived next to for 42 years. Thousands of dollars of your tax money is being spent to degrade one of the most...

Key Storage 4.14.22