hopkinton-independent-logo2x
Hopkinton, MA
loader-image
Hopkinton, US
6:14 pm, Tuesday, November 17, 2026
45°F
70 %
Wind Gust: 2 mph
Clouds: 0%
Sunrise: 6:39 am
Sunset: 4:23 pm

SIGN UP TODAY!
BREAKING NEWS & DAILY NEWSLETTER

Letter to the Editor: Van Raalten worthy to be police chief

by | Nov 17, 2026 | Letter to Editor

With so much being said publicly about Scott van Raalten and his candidacy for Hopkinton’s next chief of police, we feel it is important to share a perspective from people who actually know him.

Shawn has known Scott for 38 years, beginning in Cub Scouts. Their friendship has continued through adulthood, marriage and raising families. Scott was even a member of our wedding party. Amy has known Scott since 2012. We know him not simply as a police officer but as a friend, husband, father and dedicated member of this community. When we speak about his character and integrity, we do so from firsthand experience, not secondhand opinions.

Scott is the kind of person who would help anyone without hesitation. He approaches difficult situations with empathy, understanding and a willingness to listen. He knows that leadership is about building relationships, earning trust and bringing people together around a shared commitment.

Scott has dedicated his professional career to Hopkinton, but his service extends beyond policing. He has volunteered coaching youth football and supporting young people in the community. He understands this town and the importance of building a team equally invested in serving it.

As someone who works in public administration, Amy understands the complexity of leadership and personnel decisions. Transparency and accountability are essential, but so are fairness, confidentiality and respect for those involved. The public cannot always know every consideration behind a personnel decision, nor should confidential matters be publicly debated. We are concerned that public accusations and personal opinions have overshadowed a thoughtful evaluation of Scott’s qualifications, experience and character.

Scott brings extensive law enforcement experience, education, institutional knowledge and longstanding community relationships. These are significant strengths that deserve consideration.

We are not asking the Select Board to select Scott simply because he is our friend. We are asking that he be evaluated fairly, based on his complete record, qualifications and commitment to Hopkinton.

We have known Scott through life’s milestones and challenges. We know him to be compassionate, dependable and a man of integrity. We would not put our names behind him if we believed otherwise.

We wholeheartedly support Scott van Raalten as Hopkinton’s next chief of police.

— Amy and Shawn McDonald, Hopkinton

Editor’s note: The opinions and comments expressed in letters to the editor are those of the writers and not necessarily those of the Independent. Submissions should be no more than 400 words and must include the writer’s name and contact information for verification. Letters should be relevant and not primarily for the purpose of promoting an organization or event or thanking sponsors or volunteers. Letters may be edited by the Independent staff for space, errors or clarification, and the Independent offers no guarantee that every letter will be published. For a schedule of deadlines for letters and other submissions for the print edition, click here.

0 Comments

Submit a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Related Articles

Letter to the Editor: Support for van Raalten as police chief

I am writing to express my strong support for appointing interim Chief Scott van Raalten as the permanent chief of police for the Town of Hopkinton. Having coached youth football alongside Scott, I have seen firsthand the kind of leader, mentor and neighbor he is....

Letter to the Editor: Public Safety endorses van Raalten

On behalf of MassCOP Local 254A (Public Safety Communications), we would like to express our support for interim [Hopkinton Police Chief Scott] van Raalten as he moves through the final selection process for the permanent position of chief of police in Hopkinton....

Letter to the Editor: Kyriakides statue inspires

When I first moved to Hopkinton, my daily routine consisted of an exhausting bus ride home after a rough school day. Looking out the window, I almost always noticed a statue, what seemed like a runner being guided forward by another man. At first, it was just part...

Letter to the Editor: HHS seniors deserve DJ money

I am writing to express my strong disappointment regarding Select Board vice chair Matt Kizner’s opposition to allocating $2,000 toward a DJ for the Hopkinton High School senior class party. What makes this objection particularly frustrating is that these funds do...

Letter to the Editor: What is Town Meeting, and what should it be?

On Oct. 26, Hopkinton residents will gather for something remarkable: the opportunity to govern themselves directly. In towns like ours, voters can debate, amend and vote on local legislation — and introduce citizen petitions. But having a voice in government and...

Key Storage 4.14.22